25
Questions and Answers about Composting
- What
is composting?
- What
can be composted?
- Can
composting manage all our wastes?
- Is
composting compatible with other waste management systems?
- What
are the benefits of a successful composting program?
- Is
composting new?
THE COMPOSTING PROCESS
- What
different types of composting systems have municipalities implemented?
- How
long does the composting process take?
- What
is the best location for a backyard composter?
- Can
I compost in the winter?
- Are
there many centralized composting facilities in Canada?
- What
are the different types of centralized composting processes?
- Are
special additives required?
- Does
composting cause odours or attract rodents?
- Does
composting pose a health risk to workers or to those located near a facility?
ECONOMICS AND SITING A FACILITY
- What
is the cost of a composting facility? How does composting compare to other
waste management activities?
- How
much space is required?
- What
approvals and siting issues can I expect to encounter when planning a centralized
composting facility?
- What
is the best way to collect organic wastes?
COMPOST QUALITY
- What
makes a good quality compost?
- Are
there regulations or standards for compost quality?
- What
steps can be taken to ensure that a facility produces high quality compost?
END USES FOR COMPOST
- Are
there markets and end uses for compost?
- Is
compost a fertilizer?
- How
can I get more information about composting?
1. What is composting?
Composting is a natural
biological process, carried out under controlled conditions, which converts
organic material into a stable humus-like product called compost. During the
composting process, various microorganisms, including bacteria and fungi,
break down organic material into simpler substances. Composting is an aerobic
process, meaning that the microorganisms require oxygen to do their work.
Back
to the Top
2. What can be Composted?
Composting has the potential
to manage all of the organic material in the waste stream which cannot otherwise
be recycled. Some examples of organic material that can be composted include
food scraps, leaves and yard wastes, agricultural crop residues, paper products,
sewage sludge and wood.
Back
to the Top
3. Can composting manage all
our wastes?
Since approximately 50%
of the waste stream is organic matter, composting can play an important role
in the integrated waste management plans of any community. However, the remainder
of the waste stream (such as items made of plastic, glass, metals, ceramics
and rubber) cannot be composted.
Back
to the Top
4. Is composting compatible with
other waste management systems?
Yes. Composting should
be part of a comprehensive waste management system that emphasizes source
reduction, reuse, composting and recycling, and proper disposal of any residual
material.
Some materials (such as
paper products) can be recycled or composted. While paper can be composted,
clean paper is generally more valuable when recycled. Soiled paper or paper
that cannot be recycled economically can be composted.
Back
to the Top
5. What are the benefits of a
successful composting program?
In addition to diverting
a large proportion of the waste stream away from disposal, an effective composting
program can produce a high quality soil amendment with a variety of end uses.
Diverting organic wastes from landfill sites helps to conserve landfill space
and to reduce the production of leachate and methane gas (both of which add
to the cost of operating a landfill).
Back
to the Top
6. Is composting new?
No. Agricultural wastes
have been composted forever. Large scale composting of other organic wastes,
including municipal sewage sludge, has been a component of some municipal
waste management programs since the 1950s.
Back
to the Top
THE COMPOSTING PROCESS
7. What different types of composting
systems have municipalities implemented?
Municipal composting programs
can include a combination of backyard, on-site and centralized management
approaches for all or a portion of a municipality's waste stream. The major
differences between these approaches are described below.
- Backyard Composting
Many municipalities
encourage "Home" or "Backyard" composting, where individual households
compost at home.
- On-Site Composting
The industrial, commercial
and institutional sectors can take advantage of larger scale on-site systems
to manage their organic wastes and avoid disposal costs.
- Centralized Composting
Many organic waste
generators will not be able to compost all of their wastes on site and
therefore rely on programs to collect and compost their wastes at a centralized
facility.
Many municipalities
have implemented programs to collect and compost leaf and yard wastes
in conjunction with home composting programs.
Combined programs
for the collection of organics and recyclables, known as "wet/dry" programs
have been tested in several municipalities in Canada and the US. Full-scale
programs are being implemented in Canada.
Back
to the Top
8. How long does the composting
process take?
A number of factors are
important in controlling the composting process and the time that the process
takes. These factors include temperature, moisture, oxygen, particle size,
the carbon-to-nitrogen ratio of the waste and the degree of mixing or turning
involved. In general, the more actively these factors are controlled, the
faster the process.
The length of the process
also depends on the degree of decomposition desired in the finished product.
Typically, an immature compost can be produced in about a month, while a mature
compost may be allowed to cure for six months to a year.
Back
to the Top
9. What is the best location
for a backyard composter?
The composter should be
placed in a well drained area and where it is convenient to use. It should
be placed where it can get as much sun as possible as the microbiological
activity will be high. If the unit is placed in the shade, the activity is
reduced and the process takes longer.
Back
to the Top
10. Can I compost in the winter?
Yes, you can compost year-round.
As the temperature falls, microbial activity decreases but it starts up again
as soon as the weather warms up. To make room for your winter organics, empty
the finished compost from your unit in the fall. You may also want to move
the unit to a more accessible location for the winter. Also, organics can
be collected in a covered container stored just outside the back door. In
the spring, the collected organics can be added to your composter. Kitchen
wastes are high in nitrogen so you need to add lots of leaves or something
rich in carbon to be sure that you have the right carbon-to-nitrogen ratio
needed for the microorganisms to be most effective.
Back
to the Top
11. Are there many centralized
composting facilities in Canada?
There are about 162 centralized
composting facilities in operation or in plan across Canada. These facilities,
which include a mix of publicly- and privately-owned and operated operations,
processed almost 700,000 tonnes of organic waste in 1995, an increase of 154%
versus 1993.
Back
to the Top
12. What are the different types
of centralized composting processes?
There are three basic
types of centralized composting processes or methods.
In the In-Vessel Method,
the organic material is composted inside a drum, silo, agitated bed, covered
or open channel, batch container or other structure. The process conditions
are closely monitored and controlled and the material is aerated and mechanically
turned or agitated.
The Aerated Static
Pile Method involves forming compostable materials into large piles, which
are aerated by drawing air through the pile or forcing air out through the
pile. The pile is not turned.
In the Windrow Method,
compostable material is formed into elongated piles, known as windrows, which
are turned mechanically on a regular basis.
Back
to the Top
13. Are special additives required?
In some cases, such as
in the composting of grass clippings, the raw material may be too dense to
allow for the proper flow of air or may be too moist. A common solution to
this problem is to add a bulking agent, such as wood chips, to provide structure
to material and to allow for proper air flow. The amount of bulking agent
required is usually determined based on experience. Some facilities add commercial
fertilizers to their composting process, but this can usually be avoided by
combining different waste streams together in a specific "recipe". Inoculating
the material with microbes is not normally required, since most wastes naturally
contain the microbes needed for successful composting to occur.
Back
to the Top
14. Does composting cause odours
or attract rodents?
Any waste management facility,
including a composting site, has the potential to generate offensive odours
or to attract pests. However, experience at hundreds of composting facilities
has shown that proper design and operational procedures can prevent or control
these problems. Excessive or offensive odours are generally a sign that the
composting process is not proceeding properly, usually because of inadequate
aeration or excessive moisture. Close monitoring of these factors can usually
help to minimize odours. Facilities can employ abatement systems, such as
biofilters, to treat occasional odours. Preventing odours and ensuring that
the site is kept clean will ensure that the site does not attract rodents
or other pests.
Back
to the Top
15. Does composting pose a health
risk to workers or to those located near a facility?
Some people have expressed
a concern that certain microbes present at composting facilities and the compounds
they produce, may become airborne and endanger the health of site workers
and those located downwind of a composting facility. Studies of concentrations
of fungal spores and other airborne materials at and near composting sites
show that concentrations are higher around some composting operations, such
as turning and screening, and the levels drop to background levels within
a short distance.
While airborne concentrations
of fungal spores and other microbes at composting sites are higher than background
levels, studies of long time compost site workers show no negative health
effects.
Wherever decaying organic
matter is present, certain microbes occur naturally. Spores of the fungus
Aspergillus fumigatus are commonly cited as a source of concern. Aspergillus
fumigatus is one of the most widely distributed microorganisms on earth
is known to exist in almost every interior and exterior environment. People
are routinely exposed to low levels (and occasionally high levels) of Aspergillus
fumigatus without consequence.
The conclusion reached
by health and environmental agencies in the US and Europe is that normal,
healthy individuals suffer no increased health risk by either working at,
or living near, a compost facility. However, some individuals may be more
sensitive to microbes at a composting facility (because of a reduced resistance
resulting from drugs or disease). These individuals should not work at composting
facilities.
Back
to the Top
ECONOMICS AND SITING A FACILITY
16. What is the cost of a composting
facility? How does composting compare to other waste management activities?
Unfortunately, there is
no simple answer to this question - in part, because of the wide variety of
local circumstances that influence the cost of waste management. An accurate
estimate of the cost of a composting facility requires detailed knowledge
of project specific criteria such as location, site conditions, waste composition,
facility size and level of technology. The cost of collecting and composting
organic wastes should be evaluated as a component of an integrated system
of waste management since increased diversion through composting will result
in lower costs for collection and disposal of garbage.
Back
to the Top
17. How much space is required?
The amount of space required
for a composting operation depends greatly on a number of factors including
the quantity of waste to be handled, the composition of the waste, the system
design and operating conditions, and the length of time that the material
will be on-site. For example, an on-site, in-vessel composter in an institutional
setting can take up a minimum of space, especially if the compost is moved
elsewhere for curing. Conversely, windrow facilities can range in size from
about 1 acre to more than 20 acres.
18. What approvals and siting
issues can I expect to encounter when planning a centralized composting facility?
Most provincial governments
regard composting sites to be waste management facilities which require formal
approvals or licenses. Some provinces have exempted some types of composting
(such as leaf and yard waste facilities) from the full approval process, but
still require that they be properly sited and operated. Municipal governments
should also be consulted about by-law and other siting requirements. Most
jurisdictions are concerned about issues such as the distance to neighbours,
local soil conditions and potential impacts on local water and groundwater.
Proponents of composting facilities are strongly advised to consult the provincial
environmental department early in the planning stages to discuss siting and
other approval requirements.
Back
to the Top
19. What is the best way to collect
organic wastes?
This question continues
to generate considerable debate, despite growing experience with the collection
of organic wastes. Determining the "best" method in any circumstance will
require tradeoffs between the conflicting objectives of low cost collection
and low cost processing. For example, the use of plastic bags may lower collection
costs, but may increase the cost of processing to remove unwanted plastic.
Conversely, the use of curbside collection containers makes processing easier,
but requires more capital expenditure for collection equipment.
Back
to the Top
COMPOST QUALITY
20. What makes a good quality
compost?
Exactly what makes a good
quality compost is usually best determined by the requirements of the end
user of the material. However, there are a number of important criteria which
are normally used to judge compost quality. Among these are maturity, organic
matter content, the presence of physical contaminants (such as glass, metal
or plastic), pH, particle size, nutrient content, moisture content and trace
element content.
Back
to the Top
21. Are there regulations or
standards for compost quality?
Compost produced in Canada
may be subject to regulation by the federal and the provincial governments.
Several provinces have guidelines and standards which determine the suitability
of the material for use on a regulated or unregulated basis. Agriculture and
Agri-Food Canada regulates compost offered for sale in Canada through the
federal Fertilizers Act. The Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment
(CCME) has worked to establish national guidelines for compost quality.
In addition, the Bureau
de normalisation du Québec (BNQ), a member of the Standards Council
of Canada, has developed voluntary industry standards for compost quality.
Compost which meets this standard will be able to bear a BNQ label as an indication
of its quality.
Back
to the Top
22. What steps can be taken to
ensure that a facility produces high quality compost?
The most important step
in producing a high quality compost is to control the quality of the material
entering the process. This is most often achieved through source separation.
Source-separated organics are those organic wastes which have been separated
from potential contaminants prior to collection. Other contaminants can be
removed through a pre-processing stage or by screening the final compost.
Finally, the composting process itself can determine some characteristics
of the final compost, such as maturity and particle size.
Back
to the Top
END USES FOR COMPOST
23. Are there markets and end
uses for compost?
Compost can be used in
many applications depending on the quality produced and the quality of the
product. High quality compost is being used in agriculture, horticulture,
landscaping and home gardening. Medium quality compost can be used in applications
such as erosion control and roadside landscaping. Even low quality compost
can be used as a landfill cover or in land reclamation projects.
Back
to the Top
24. Is compost a fertilizer?
Compost can contain varying
amounts of nutrients such as nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium. However,
the concentrations of these nutrients in compost are usually lower than those
found in common fertilizers.
Compost is more properly
described as a soil amendment or soil conditioner which returns valuable organic
material to the soil. In addition, compost does benefit the soil be improving
soil structure, aeration and water retention.
Back
to the Top
25. How can I get more information
about composting?
For additional information
about composting, please write The Composting Council of Canada at
16 Northumberland Street, Toronto, Ontario M6H 1P7 or Email us at
info@compost.org. Specific information
about the composting initiatives in your community may obtained by calling
your local municipal recycling and composting.
Back
to the Top
|